On October 23rd 1993 Robert Latimer from Battleford, Saskatchewan
“drowned” his 12 year old daughter Tracy with Carbon Monoxide in the cab of his truck while he watched, timed the process and waited. He set about his plan as soon as his wife and children left for church.
This was an act he had contemplated for at least five days after Tracy had returned from the doctor with the date for her hip surgery and coincidentally the same day the family were offered a fulltime placement for Tracy in the Centre in North Battleford.
He destroyed the evidence, placed Tracy back in bed and pretended he knew nothing, either to his family or even to police.
Court testimony establishes that he had considered and weighed up how he would kill Tracy, for almost a week.
Latimer admitted that he thought about combining an overdose of valium, shooting her in the head, or burning her with fire.
Finally he decided upon gassing (drowning) her with carbon monoxide, and the rest is history. Latimer has never shown remorse and now in an exclusive interview on Radio-Canada he wants a new trial and is said to be angered over how he was treated. Well tough! In my estimation you got off too (ten years in prison) lightly for such a callous, pre-meditated murder of a twelve year old who had the right to depend on and trust you to protect and care for her.
What makes me saddest of all is that many Canadians would describe Latimer as a “good father” and agree with him that he should not be punished you know why? – Because Tracy had Cerebral Palsy and lived with multiple disabilities. She attended school, family gatherings and would only wear red nail varnish, loved watching bonfires and windscreen wipers!!
Let’s switch for a second to another father here in Chatham, Ontario. In June 1999 these words rang out in an Ontario Court to Thomas Dewald, who just like Robert Latimer, showed no remorse for the murder of his children.
Thomas Dewald drowned his two children Christopher 12 and Jennifer 10 in Lake Eyrie, he held them down until they drowned. Judge Thompson’s sentencing remarks included the following;
“I have no doubt that a parent murdering their child is the worst possible breach of trust…It is without doubt, an example of the worst crime by the worst offender..The Public must know that the courts will not tolerate a breach of trust of this magnitude. It is the duty of the media to get the message out that the safety of our children is a sacred trust that must be protected at all costs..”
It is recorded that Judge Thompson in a voice of icy contempt told Thomas Dewald, “What you did was contemptible, despicable, disgusting and cowardly”.
Judge Thompson doubled Dewald’s sentence to 23 years with no eligibility for release until 2022.
Why is Thomas Dewald in prison and Robert Latimer free? The only difference I can see is that Christopher and Jennifer were able bodied children and Tracy was not.
Surely, Judge Thompson’s words should be repeated to Robert Latimer. What you did was contemptible, despicable, disgusting and cowardly and you belong in jail and someone should have thrown away the key.
We cannot tolerate two levels of justice, one for those who kill the able bodied and one for those who kill Canadians living with one or more disabilities.
Jakki